Persephone Productions
  • Home
  • The Company
    • Mission
    • Meet The Director
    • History
    • Awards
    • Notable Alumni
    • In The Press
    • Feedback
  • Past Productions
    • Blue Stockings >
      • Meet the Artists
      • Production Gallery
      • In the Press
      • Audience Feedback
    • Counting Aloud
    • Abigail/1702
    • Jerome of Sandy Cove
    • Compleat Female Stage Beauty
    • Moby Dick >
      • MD - Press Release /Communique de presse
      • Moby Dick - Production Notes
    • 2015 GALA
    • Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde >
      • Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde Press
    • The Nisei & The Narnauks >
      • The Nisei & The Narnauks Press
    • Spring Awakening: The Musical >
      • Spring Awakening: The Musical 2014
    • Strawberries in January
    • The Walnut Tree >
      • Press Release - The Walnut Tree
    • Spring Awakening: The Musical
    • Lost: A Memoir >
      • Lost: A Memoir Press >
        • The Westmount Independent Review for Lost: A Memoir
        • The Gazette Preview for Lost: A Memoir
    • Oroonoko >
      • Oroonoko Press >
        • The Gazette Review for Oroonoko
        • The Charlebois Post Review for Oroonoko
        • The Montrealer Interview with Paul Van Dyck for Oroonoko
    • Hamlet >
      • Hamlet Press >
        • First Person Charlebois Post by Christopher for Hamlet
        • CBC Interview with Gabrielle Soskin
        • The McGill Tribune Review for Hamlet
        • The Métropolitain Review for Hamlet
        • The Senior Times Review for Hamlet
    • To Be >
      • To Be Press >
        • Mirror Review for To Be
        • Charlebois Post First Person for To Be
    • Far from the Madding Crowd >
      • Far from the Madding Crowd Press >
        • Gazette Review for FFTMC
        • Mirror Review for FFTMC
        • Gazette Preview on Christopher Moore for FFTMC
        • Charlebois Post for FFTMC
    • Mary's Wedding >
      • Mary's Wedding Press >
        • Charlebois Post Interview with Gabrielle Soskin for Mary's Wedding
        • Canadian Jewish News Preview for Mary's Wedding
        • The Mirror Preview for Mary's Wedding
        • Charlebois Post Preview for Mary's Wedding
    • Henry V >
      • Henry V Press >
        • The Suburban Preview for Henry V
        • The Gazette Review for Henry V
        • Rover Arts Report for Henry V
        • Midnight Poutine Review for Henry V
        • Coolopolis Review for Henry V
        • Rover Arts Review for Henry V
    • Ten year Anniversary Gala
    • Be My Baby >
      • Be My Baby Press >
        • Gazette Preview for Be My Baby
        • Gazette Review for Be My Baby
        • The West End Times Preview for Be My Baby
        • The Suburban Review for Be My Baby
    • Cherry Docs >
      • Cherry Docs Press >
        • The Gazette (Cherry Docs)
        • The Suburban (Cherry Docs)
        • Rover Arts (Cherry Docs)
        • Dee Arr (Cherry Docs)
        • The Canadian Jewish News (Cherry Docs)
        • HOUR (Cherry Docs)
        • The Mirror (Cherry Docs)
        • Stanstead Journal (Cherry Docs)
    • Othello >
      • Othello Press >
        • The Gazette (Othello)
        • The Concordian (Othello)
        • The Link (Othello)
        • MicGill Tribune (Othello)
        • The Westmount Independent (Othello)
        • The NDG Monitor (Othello)
    • The Love of Shakespeare's Women (2)
    • Unity 1918 >
      • Unity 1918 Press >
        • The Gazette (Unity 1918)
        • The Mirror (Unity 1918)
        • Invisible Cities Network (Unity 1918)
        • McGill Tribune (Unity 1918)
        • HOUR (Unity 1918)
    • The Love of Shakespeare's Women (1) >
      • The Love of Shakespeare's Women Press >
        • The Westmount Independent (The Loves of Shakespeare's Women)
        • The Gazette (The Loves of Shakespeare's Women)
    • To the Green Fields Beyond >
      • To The Green Fields Beyond Press >
        • The Gazette (To The Green Fields Beyond)
        • The Mirror (To The Green Fields Beyond)
    • Prodigy >
      • Prodigy Press >
        • The Gazette (Prodigy)
        • La Press (Prodigy)
        • Le Délit (Prodigy)
        • Invisible Cities Network (Prodigy)
        • McGill Tribune (Prodigy)
        • The Surban (Prodigy)
        • The Mirror (Prodigy)
        • McGill Daily (Prodigy)
    • Spring Awakening >
      • Spring Awakening Press >
        • The Gazette (Spring Awakening)
        • Prince Chameleon Press (Spring Awakening)
        • Délit (Spring Awakening)
        • Mon Theatre (Spring Awakening)
    • A Room of One's Own >
      • A Room of One's Own Press >
        • CBC Radio One (A Room of One's Own)
        • The Gazette (A Room of One's Own)
        • The Westmount Examiner (A Room of One's Own)
        • The Canadian Jewish News (A Room of One's Own)
    • SubUrbia >
      • SubUrbia Press >
        • CBC Radio One(SubUrbia)
        • The Gazette (SubUrbia)
        • Montreal Mirror (SubUrbia)
        • HOUR (SubUrbia)
        • The Suburban (SubUrbia)
        • Westmount Times (SubUrbia)
        • The Canadian Jewish News (SubUrbia)
    • Jane Eyre >
      • Jane Eyre Press >
        • The Canadian Jewish News (Jane Eyre)
        • Orcasound (Jane Eyre)
    • West
    • Kindertransport >
      • Kindertransport Press >
        • The Gazette (Kindertransport)
        • Montreal Mirror (Kindertransport)
        • The Suburban (Kindertransport)
        • The Chronicle (Kindertransport)
    • Playhouse Creatures >
      • In The Press - Playhouse Creatures
    • Anna Karenina >
      • In The Press - Anna Karenina
  • Blog
  • Newsletter
  • Support
  • Contact
  • FR

The Prism of Brutal History

Does presenting the unimaginable remind, trivialize or flatten?,

By Caitlin Murphy/ The Charlebois Post / February 7, 2013

Boasting live music, choreographed dance, fight sequences, period costumes, and 13 performers, Oroonoko, written and directed by Paul Van Dyck, and presented by Persephone Productions, is an ambitious piece of theatre that is both well-made and well-played. 

Based on Aphra Behn's 1688 novel of the same title, Oroonoko recounts the story of a young African prince, captured under false pretences and taken as a slave to an English colony in the West Indies. Through some first person narration in the novel, Behn - one of the first professional female writers - positions herself as actual witness to the events she describes (though the truth or extent of her personal involvement is unverifiable). In the play, to mirror this narration, a dramatic framing device is used, in which Behn (Rebecca Croll) recounts the prince's story to Clarice (Shannon Hamilton), an eager, new devotee. The action of the play moves between Oronooko's life and Behn's narration of it.

The 'event' here is slavery, of course, but I'm not sure it risks being trivialized so much as flattened.

The several required settings for the piece - tents, ships, labyrinths, plantations - were all brilliantly conveyed with only a large, white sheet, a few poles and a pulley-system manipulated by the performers. The clever simplicity of the design was supremely efficient and elegant, allowing numerous opportunities for dynamic staging and set changes.

Jaa Smith-Johnson, as Oroonoko is a committed and compelling performer; he's got an intensity of presence that grabs you. Rebecca Croll delivers a majestic Aphra Behn full of wit and command, though she tends to get a bit stuck there. Indeed, performances were strong across the board, but everyone risked at times becoming a bit one-note, falling into comfortable cadences. Accents were handled quite admirably.

For being based on such a short novel, the play is quite long. Some scenes felt a bit overwritten and could have accomplished the same goals with trimming. At some points, exchanges between characters fell into a lulling evenness of tone, or else the blocking got a bit staid - greater modulation in places and a tighter pace would keep things more vibrant and moving along a bit more.

In his program notes, Van Dyck contends that "By telling one story in the context of a greater historical event, the risk of trivializing the event is ever present." The 'event' here is slavery, of course, but I'm not sure it risks being trivialized so much as flattened.

The images of slavery have been so repeated as to become iconic. We are dangerously accustomed to them. I'm not sure that seeing again a half-naked black man, being bound and beaten can offer anything new, which is not the same thing as saying that we don't need reminding of the evils of oppression. We absolutely do. But the repetition of such imagery becomes quickly fraught, for me, and borderline fetishistic. I don't think we know how to actually see it anymore. Documentary filmmaker Claude Lanzmann, who made the film Shoah, thought that portraying the Holocaust through piles of shoes or bodies, for instance, was obscene. There's just something about reducing unimagineable horrors to physical facts or familiar images that quickly becomes problematic, despite all of our intentions otherwise. I'm not sure how we avoid this; but I think the process of de-familiarizing people might be central.

As a seemingly rather straight adaptation of Behn's novel, Oroonoko is really quite a stellar piece of theatre. The set, the staging, the performances, the costumes - all aspects were accomplished and impressive. Something about the production just didn't feel vital to me though. Why this particular slave narrative? Why re-told now? Something felt a bit too tidy and resolved about it all, like an easy re-iteration of the obvious truth that slavery was despicable. Though Behn feels guilty that she never helped Oroonoko, her connection to his story feels weak and primarily exploitative, (something the play's final line confirms) a hard truth that's left unexamined. And I wondered if our connection to him doesn't unintentionally wind up feeling a bit the same.

Persephone Productions Inc
93, Somerville Ave.,
Westmount, Que, H3Z 1J4

CONTACT
ABOUT